11 May
2018
11 May
'18
2:14 a.m.
Hi David,
I have used the RB1100AHx2 and currently have the CCR1009-7G-1C-1Splus.
The latter fulfills all your requirements, and so does the RB1100AHx4,
without any issues regarding performance.
But unless you have a need for the SFP and SFP+ slots, I would rather
recommend the RB1100AHx4 Dude Edition.
This one has an internal SSD disk, which allows you to run 2
applications which are problematic without it and which you may want to
have.
- The Dude Server - which is a nice monitoring tool which needs storage
space and is write intensive. It could be run on a SD card, but it fares
better on the SSD
- The user manager, a light Radius implementation, which also works
better on the SSD
The AHx4 Dude Edition also allows you to add additional storage via MII
or SATA, which may come in handy, and supplementary allows a telecom
power supply.
Marius, YO2LOJ
On 11.05.2018 07:23, David Ranch wrote:
>
> Hello Everyone,
>
> Considering there is a good chunk of routing-savvy HAMs here, I
> thought I'd use you as a sounding board on what would be a good router
> to buy. Specifically, I have a project to consolidate the current
> adhoc setup of three consumer grade "routers" to one larger, better
> router. I'm considering something like a:
>
> https://mikrotik.com/product/CCR1009-7G-1C-1Splus
> <https://mikrotik.com/product/CCR1009-7G-1C-1Splus>
>
> or maybe https://mikrotik.com/product/rb1100ahx4
> <https://mikrotik.com/product/rb1100ahx4>
>
>
> I'm looking for something that is:
> - very stable
> - offer long term software updates (a support contract might be fine)
> - Has strong support for IPv4 NAT (to better the consumer routers
> mentioned above) for the three IPs we have onsite
> - maybe some L2 segmenting and vlan'ing support for traffic isolation
> - has performance to grow into
> - has a decent GUI UI for others in the club who can't / won't cope
> with a CLI
> - ACLs to limit incoming traffic to specific hosts (say limit RDP
> traffic to just some people to some hosts, etc)
> - maybe.. just maybe support SSL VPNs or IPSEC
> - maybe dual power supplies
> - stretch goal: native support for IPv6
> - I have no need for dynamic routing protocols. This is a single
> site and statics are fine
>
>
> For background on our needs, the site supports a multi-RF link
> repeater system has:
>
> - two unique IRLP nodes (low use)
> - one Echolink node (low use)
> - one WIresX enabled Yaesu System Fusion repeater (decent use)
> - One three band Icom Dstar stack (1.2Ghz DD system as well)
> (decent use)
> - One Internet enabled Motorola DMR repeater (decent use)
> - backhaul of rarely used multi-county 3.4Ghz wifi network
> - other random needs for remote management (SSH, RDP, etc)
>
>
> I believe something like a Miktrotik would be fine for our low-end
> needs but maybe something from Ubiquiti or others would be fine. I'm
> perfectly comfortable with a CLI and I'm decently versed in Mikrotik
> (a bit weird of a UI), IOS (but I don't want to pay for Cisco prices,
> JUNOS (same point), etc. I personally think a lot of the lower tier
> vendor's products have come a LONG way so I don't need/want/care for
> "carrier" grade.
>
>
> If you have any other recommendations for a quality but not too
> expensive router, I'd love to hear it!
>
> --David
> KI6ZHD
>