-----Original Message-----
With all that said, is there anyone out there performing intermediate
routing... what I mean is anyone running a tunneled gateway and
performing routing for other subnets over RF.
I presume you mean routing other subnets over amateur radio frequencies.
We used to do that. But there are two main problems with it here in the US.
1) Encryption. More than half of websites are now encrypted and the percentage is
growing every day. E-mail encryption is also on the rise. And encryption is not allowed
over US amateur frequencies. So amateur frequencies are fast becoming
impractical/irrelevant for real-world, mainstream network traffic.
2) 3rd party-initiated traffic. Routing inbound e-mail, even if unencrypted, over an
amateur frequency is a violation of Part 97, according to the FCC enforcement bureau. At
least it was when I asked them about this a few years ago. That's because anyone
anywhere could initiate a transmission on an amateur frequency without a license simply by
sending you an email. So we allowed only outbound email from hams to traverse the amateur
frequencies. Inbound email stopped at the gateway. It wasn't very practical, but at
least a message could go out.
We later got internet connections at all of our hub sites. So we turned each of them into
their own gateways. Users can access the site over amateur frequencies to download their
mail since the ham initiates that connection. But we still have to filter out encrypted
email. And we're using Part 15 frequencies between hub sites. I suppose we could
still use 44.x addresses. But since a 44.x subnet can only exist behind one gateway in
AMPRnet routing, we didn't see much point in that either.
Not trying to be a bummer. But the FCC regulations really squash creativity and
innovation.
Michael
N6MEF