> AMPRNet / HamNet routing is quite complicated for
a non-IT guy...
The advantage of using BGP even in this trivial case
is...
I don't think the most important question is about selling BGP or any
particular technology (I'm well versed in internetwork engineering and
worked in that field professionally for many years; I'm in academia
now).
I'm writing this because education was a specific question in the
survey.
The reason that we have amateur radio is to enable experimentation with
using the radio spectrum in a way that is otherwise not permitted or
practical. With the Internet, there are certain things that are only
possible to experiment with if you have your own addresses and other
network numbers. AMPRNet is (perhaps that's too strong, and we could
say, "can be") a way of enabling a kind of experimentation on the
Internet similar to what we do with the radio spectrum.
Putting the Internet on a similar footing to radio as an object of
experimentation is not what every amateur radio operator wants to do --
for some, their interests and even their identity is bound up in radio.
The Internet is something else. For others, the interest is in ways of
communicating and they have a very similar character.
Much of what we learn from radio is about point to point communication.
A QSO doesn't classically involve an intermediary. But then we have
repeaters and digipeters that pass traffic. Those are single
intermediaries and are very simple to understand. Beyond that, sometimes
we invent ways of networking repeaters (typically very differently from
the way that packet-switched networks function). That starts to get into
territory that is not well-understood by many of the users, or indeed
some of the operators of the repeaters.
We also have an old practice of manual message passing. That process
resembles packet-switched networking in some ways, though the rule for
how to decide where to pass a message to is not always clearly defined.
There is, it seems to me, a cluster of topics that can be described
as, "how can messages be passed across a network", that most amateur
radio operators, and most users of the Internet are never exposed to.
How does these actually work in practice? Where does this mysterious
thing called BGP that people seem to think is so difficult fit in? How
can messages be passed between all of these different networks to get to
their intended destination? This is a gap that could usefully be
addressed by developing material within or around AMPRNet.
73s William VE0HAK