I am not proposing hardware over software, but merely alternatives. I like hardware appliances purpose built for a single task. And, it is what I know. The beauty of this community is that no solution is off the table and everything works. It is nice to have options as they all can work together.
To further cross hardware and software barriers, some Cisco switches do run Linux.
At the end of the day, all connectivity to the 44net still relies on commodity Internet service as its backbone. That is the limitation we are all faced with.
Jesse WC3XS
Actually, Linux on x86 hardware is just as much of a "hardware-based" solution as any proprietary OS on proprietary hardware is. In fact, Linux on x86 easily outperforms most proprietary hardware solutions up to and beyond the Cisco 7x00 range, especially with the current Intel architecture systems. Vyatta (now part of Brocade) and others have proven that over and over for the last several years.
I hope we can establish something that's vendor neutral, rather than any type of single vendor lock-in.
Michael N6MEF
In the performance class we are operating in, "hardware based" is not really required. A suitable box (processor and ethernet interfaces) and software (e.g. Linux plus some usermode tools) can do the same thing.
44Net mailing list 44Net@hamradio.ucsd.edu http://hamradio.ucsd.edu/mailman/listinfo/44net http://www.ampr.org/donate.html