Le 19/04/2018 à 17:25, Christopher S. Munz-Michielin a écrit :
I agree with Jann's comment that it would be useful to have these services located within a dedicated allocation to prevent Ampr-Internet routing complexity.
That's already what most people do. Some time ago, I had a look at the D-Star hosts file : only 1% of the IPs were using 44.0.0.0 space.
My personal opinion is that amateur radio guys should use amateur radio IP addresses whenever possible. And amateur radio network operators should make ise of those IP easier for everybody.
Our approach here in Corsica is to consider our AMPR allocation as we could consider an enterprise network : - Some machines are "private" (in the "amateur radio" meaning). These will be on "LAN". - Some other machines, such as a WEB server (or D-Star repeater), need public Internet access. These would be put in a "DMZ"
Then, we'll split our allocation into LANs and DMZs. Access rules will be managed by firewalls. But IP routing will be direct, with no more NAT or dual-addressing. That's a first step to what we'll have to do when we decide to migrate to IPv6, HI :-)
73 de TK1BI