Brian and Brian, Thanks so much! The 157 address actually goes to the wrong machine now, I'll update that to reflect the correct address. And thanks as well for the link to the white paper. I had read that before, but I've actually never been able to get IPIP working on Comcast.
I had originally thought that I had ampr-ripd configured improperly but I was able to get it working on the 157 machine, which is a vps I'm getting rid of.
Even in bridge mode I wasn't getting any traffic from AMPRGW. Tomorrow I will try bridge mode again, it is possible that I may have set up the firewall rules on my edgerouter incorrectly. Thanks, -Nate
On Fri, Jul 12, 2019, 2:50 AM Brian Kantor Brian@bkantor.net wrote:
On Fri, Jul 12, 2019 at 02:27:15AM -0700, Nate Sales via 44Net wrote:
Date: Fri, 12 Jul 2019 02:27:15 -0700 From: Nate Sales nate.wsales@gmail.com To: AMPRNet working group 44net@mailman.ampr.org Subject: Comcast Xfinity Routing
Hello, I'm wondering if anyone here has had success with an IPIP gateway on Xfinity by Comcast. I haven't had a lot of success with it, and I'm wondering if even in "bridge" mode the CPE modem/router that they give
you
is still blocking protocol 4. 73, KJ7DMC
Nate:
Whatever your current modem configuration is, it's blocking protocol 4 (IPIP).
Specifically, a traceroute to your gateway, 157.230.161.245 using ordinary UDP traceroute succeeds. Doing the same thing with protocol 4 (IPIP) gets a "Protocol Unreachable" ICMP return from your gateway. Viz:
# traceroute -n 157.230.161.245 traceroute to 157.230.161.245 (157.230.161.245), 64 hops max, 40 byte packets 1 169.228.34.82 0.575 ms 0.569 ms 0.561 ms 2 132.239.255.49 0.223 ms 0.206 ms 0.200 ms 3 132.239.254.162 0.247 ms 0.536 ms 0.235 ms 4 132.239.254.149 0.356 ms 0.393 ms 0.265 ms 5 137.164.23.57 2.871 ms 2.841 ms 2.740 ms 6 137.164.22.46 5.335 ms 137.164.11.2 5.129 ms 137.164.22.46 5.165 ms 7 4.35.156.65 4.972 ms 4.911 ms 4.968 ms 8 * * * 9 4.14.33.70 12.617 ms 19.749 ms 4.14.33.54 14.277 ms 10 * * * 11 * * * 12 157.230.161.245 13.960 ms 12.958 ms 14.074 ms
...and...
# traceroute -n -P 4 157.230.161.245 traceroute to 157.230.161.245 (157.230.161.245), 64 hops max, 40 byte packets 1 169.228.34.82 0.613 ms 0.611 ms 0.577 ms 2 132.239.255.49 0.218 ms 0.197 ms 0.215 ms 3 132.239.254.162 0.363 ms 0.227 ms 0.224 ms 4 132.239.254.149 0.364 ms 0.258 ms 0.263 ms 5 137.164.23.57 3.111 ms 3.025 ms 3.108 ms 6 137.164.11.2 5.091 ms 5.122 ms 5.094 ms 7 4.35.156.65 5.219 ms 4.967 ms 4.974 ms 8 * * * 9 4.14.33.70 13.814 ms 13.901 ms 13.844 ms 10 * * * 11 * * * 12 157.230.161.245 14.829 ms !P 14.102 ms !P 13.926 ms !P
- Brian