7 Mar
2016
7 Mar
'16
3:11 p.m.
Subject:
Re: [44net] Is there raceroutre machine on 44 net available for public ?
From:
Antonio Querubin <tony(a)lavanauts.org>
Date:
03/07/2016 08:52 PM
To:
AMPRNet working group <44net(a)hamradio.ucsd.edu>
You should NOT assume that all gateways actually have the entire mesh encap table loaded.
Some only load a partial table to those networks they want to reach. You'd have to
check with each gateway operator to verify which encap routes are
actually loaded if you can't reach any of the net-44 nodes behind their gateway.
And of course the encap table does not tell you anything about which 44-net address is
used by the gateway itself.
So there is no way you can check if you can reach the gateway.
(even if you would know the address of the gateway there is no guarantee that it will
reply to detection attempts)
It has already been made clear to mr "Please Advice" that lots of operators do
not appreciate what he is doing.
Unfortunately, he rarely listens to the advice he is constantly asking for....
Rob
7 Mar
7 Mar
3:54 p.m.
New subject: Is there raceroutre machine on 44 net available for public ?
Dear Rob
Do you have any way to check connectivity and routing problem without doing at least ping
and trace route ?
I dont know ...
Whats the point to put the encap file if you cant use it ? Why should i have got
donation of Cisco2851 that will have capability to hold all the 520 lines of the
networks if they cant be accessed ?
I could have left my 1005 give it only one route line and let the Local hams go to the
InterNet
But thats not (at least what i think) the meaning of the AMPRNet it supposed to be a
Mesh network but
cant access all the part of it ( i suspect that it is because of some configuration
which is not fully set )
By the way im not the fiirst one who do trace route almost every new gateway operator
have the same problem I face and check it in the first stage of his gateway i have
seen here (on the list) more then once traceroute posted here to help and solve routing
(or connectivity ) problems
Best Regards
Ronen - 4Z4ZQ
http://www.ronen.org
________________________________________
From: 44Net <44net-bounces+ronenp=hotmail.com(a)hamradio.ucsd.edu> on behalf of Rob
Janssen <pe1chl(a)amsat.org>
Sent: Monday, March 7, 2016 12:11 PM
To: 44net(a)hamradio.ucsd.edu
Subject: Re: [44net] Is there raceroutre machine on 44 net available for public ?
(Please trim inclusions from previous messages)
_______________________________________________
Subject:
Re: [44net] Is there raceroutre machine on 44 net available for public ?
From:
Antonio Querubin <tony(a)lavanauts.org>
Date:
03/07/2016 08:52 PM
To:
AMPRNet working group <44net(a)hamradio.ucsd.edu>
You should NOT assume that all gateways actually have the entire mesh encap table loaded.
Some only load a partial table to those networks they want to reach. You'd have to
check with each gateway operator to verify which encap routes are
actually loaded if you can't reach any of the net-44 nodes behind their gateway.
And of course the encap table does not tell you anything about which 44-net address is
used by the gateway itself.
So there is no way you can check if you can reach the gateway.
(even if you would know the address of the gateway there is no guarantee that it will
reply to detection attempts)
It has already been made clear to mr "Please Advice" that lots of operators do
not appreciate what he is doing.
Unfortunately, he rarely listens to the advice he is constantly asking for....
Rob
3182
days inactive
3182
days old
1 comments
2 participants
participants (2)
-
R P -
Rob Janssen