What happned if I want to connect your DMR repeaters
to ours (we have one DMR connected to the MARC network) and my DMR sit on Non AMPR adress
?
I am not an expert on the DMR network, but I think it works with a "master"
server that everyone connects his repeater to.
We are running the BrandMeister master server. It is not the MARC network, it is an open
network.
(a 3rd network exists, it is called DMR+ )
Our new master server (currently being setup) is dual-homed, it has both an AMPR and a
normal IP address.
However that does not really matter as our AMPR addresses are BGP routed on internet as
well.
as for the P25 it is a solution that was done by by
few hams last year it consist of a server software Free one (i know of only one server
currently and there are about 13 repeaters connected world wide )
you can read it
herehttp://communications.support/threads/4798-IP-link-Quantar-V-24-systems-using-Cisco-routers
Ok, it apparently has a serial port and the Cisco routers are used to tunnel that over
IP.
Nice when you already have them, if not I would go for a Raspberry Pi and a USB Serial
cable.
Much cheaper, much more power efficient.
A 2600 or 2800 can do more useful things than working as a serial server, but of course it
can do this and routing in parallel.
The DMR and D-Star repeaters have an ethernet connection so they are easier to integrate
with the network.
We also have some Yaesu System Fusion repeaters (they are cheap), but this is crap.
No network interface. They require a separate box to interface to the outside world.
This still has no network interface,
it has USB. Then you need a computer with USB and network to connect it. But this
computer has to run Windows :-(
Not good for a repeater site...
And the whole thing is far, far from finished. Updates to implement even basic
functionality are being promised and
then being postponed all the time. I think it will not be usable before some amateurs
roll up their sleeves and
re-do the entire software, much like DMR+ and BrandMeister.
I still didnt leave the Cisco Gateway idea i will get
tomorrow hopefully Cisco 2800 and see if it can work with 300 Tunnels if not it will
go to the P25 connection Project
Please understand that (also written by Brian in the meantime) that your router will never
be able to perform this task standalone,
you will need to have a second computer that is reconfiguring the router all the time, for
every change in IP address of a gateway
or other change in the gateway list you will need to make a config change. A good script
can do that automatically, but you will
need something like a Raspberry Pi to run it on.
And the Raspberry Pi can do a better job itself, because it can track the AMPR RIP packets
and does not need to download the encap
file all the time.
however some good guy saw my request on the local
hams facebook about the Pi Board (with the link you provided) and willing to give me a
configured board for tests , if it will be reliable it tern out that ill leave the cisco
idea
Reliability will not be a problem (unless you have a bad SD card or bad powersupply).
The only thing to worry about is if you can sysop the system on the long run.
I.e. install updates sometimes, configure firewall rules as needed, etc.
This will require some study but it is part of the fun, I think.
one more question (Personal one) are you the Rob
Jebsen who was involved in the Jnos Software long ago ? I think I used one of your Jnos
version the call sign was PE1CHL in the Days that our gateways was a Jnos/Dos
Yes I am the same person, see mail address.
I was not active with JNOS but I maintained a version of KA9Q NET that was used on many
hybrid IP / NET/ROM nodes and BBS systems.
I still run that program on the hosted Raspberry Pi that is also my gateway.
Rob